Blog (EN)

What is FACIPULATION, and is it a friend or foe of team sessions?

When designing and running team sessions, a coach or facilitator risks falling into a trap between the wish to help the main client and Ethics. Michael Wilkinson, mentioned in my previous post, called this facipulation: “Facilitators should not engage in ‘facipulation’; in other words, you must not use facilitation skills to try to manipulate a group and push it towards a predetermined decision.”
What does facipulation look like in practice? And who is at greatest risk of becoming a facipulator?
Sad as it is, the higher the sector expertise of the facilitator or coach leading a team session, the greater the risk of crossing the line of a neutral position and slipping into unsolicited mentoring.
1️⃣ In the course of a session the person leading it may, not without reason, think that they know the answer to the question facing the group, and with their leading answers push the group towards a solution. Sometimes they may even switch on a “mentor’s minute”, hand out valuable expert knowledge and advice, and the group will have to make a decision not on the basis of its own mood and knowledge but using what it has been given unasked.
💊 Such a situation can be avoided or softened if the coach or facilitator, understanding that their expertise may be appropriate, obtains the group’s consent (better still, a direct request) for a “lecture on a given topic”, and informs the group that at that moment they cease to be a facilitator and move into another role. When the lecture or advice is over, the facilitator tells the group again that they are returning to the role of session leader and are ceasing to “deliver their expertise”.
2️⃣ When designing a session, the facilitator or coach knows in advance which answer or which decisions they want to get from the group, and builds the session in such a way, and with such tools, that they will very probably lead to the expected result.
🧨 The catch with this kind of work is the following: decisions made at a facipulated session will never be put into practice, because the participants were “intoxicated” in the moment, and later they will “wake up” and realise that they were deceived somewhere. Yet formally there will be nothing to find fault with — the client may be satisfied, the participants rate the session highly, but the session has no result.
💊 This course of events can be avoided only by double-checking at every step of designing the session: “Who wants this result?” And if the answer suddenly turns out to be “I do”, it makes sense to dig a little deeper — does the session leader have the right at that moment to have their own wishes regarding the outcome of the session, and how will they “work off” the rollback of the results afterwards.
3️⃣ The most difficult case is when it is the client who insists on facipulation, that is, on forcibly leading the group to the expected decisions. Alas, this happens! In that case the wording is roughly: “I have already decided what they should do next, but I want them to feel that they made the decision themselves” or “We need ________ to be adopted in this particular form”. Here the facilitator is in effect offered a deal with their conscience — the client pays and calls the tune, and if you dance the wrong dance, there is a risk of losing that client.
🪄 Even in such a situation you can turn the game around! The good news is that most clients who have come consciously to the idea of a team session act sincerely for the good and want sustainable interaction with their team. So when the possibility of manipulating the results is mentioned ethically and the consequences are pointed out, they themselves give up the idea and ask to exclude any possibility of manipulation at the session.
And in all other cases it is the lot of the facilitator or coach to come to terms with their conscience…
Personally, I am definitely for ETHICS